Councilwoman Inna Vernikov was arrested and charged after she allegedly brought a firearm to a Brooklyn protest, police said.

she violated the recently passed city law that prohibits civilians from bringing firearms to protests, the police said

At no point in time was anyone menaced or injured as a result of her possessing the firearm

Unless she was threatening someone (the article specifically claims she wasn’t), she will be acquitted. One does not have just one right at a time, one has all their rights all the time.

  • shalafi@lemmy.world
    142·
    1 year ago

    Interesting case as Bruen seems to have made the local law invalid.

    OTOH, I don’t think was meant to be a test case. Sounds like someone saw a person with a gun, had a panic attack and called the cops.

    Although the councilwoman has a concealed carry permit, she violated the recently passed city law that prohibits civilians from bringing firearms to protests, the police said.

    Remember kids! If you practice one right, you must give up another!

    Lemmy: 1A blocked? RAGE!

    Lemmy: 2A? Meh, I’m fine with that.

  • BombOmOm@lemmy.worldOP
    116·
    1 year ago

    she violated the recently passed city law that prohibits civilians from bringing firearms to protests, the police said

    At no point in time was anyone menaced or injured as a result of her possessing the firearm

    Unless she was threatening someone (the article specifically claims she wasn’t), she will be acquitted. One does not have just one right at a time, one has all their rights all the time.

      • SokathHisEyesOpen@lemmy.ml
        91·
        1 year ago

        It’ll definitely get struck down if it makes it that far. You have a right to protest, and you have a right to carry a firearm. They can’t state that you don’t have some of your rights when exercising other rights.

        Edit: this is assuming you can even carry a firearm in NYC, which seems unlikely. I know that when I visited, I checked if I could carry my pocketknife and the answer was no, which seems really fucking lame to someone who has carried a pocket knife his entire life.