Both host content that are against our content policy and have had issues with users from those sites entering our community crossposting content that violates our content policy. We are discussing defederating other instances as well. There is discussion of lemmit.online being defederated because it pretty much exclusively scrapes reddit content and reposts it, and some content creators have expressed discomfort. If there’s other instances that might be worth considering defederating from, just post and it’ll be added to the current discussion.

and before anyone brings it up, lemmygrad defederated with us.

This isn’t a dictatorship but I ask that you please behave in the comment section and at least try to understand why we are defederating.

  • @nsfwaccount411
    link
    English
    10
    edit-2
    1 year ago

    Question: If moderations tools improve and allow, say, communities from certain instances to [edit: NOT] show up on “All”/“Communities”, will it be possible to re-federate instances that allow some communities that are against the content policy?

    Most (but not all) of the banned content on here is straight up illegal so it’s not such a huge deal ATM, but (for example, as this is the most obvious “not-illegal-but-still-banned” content I can think of) anyone into CNC can’t subscribe to it here (fair) but also can’t subscribe to an external CNC community either. This may become a bigger problem as the Content Policy expands (as an extreme example, I’ve seen people call for the ban of ALL non-original content, which would be great for ethics but would basically require disabling federation altogether).

    EDIT: oof, even hentai cnc is banned. I’ve expanded further down the thread, but from a user’s perspective this really sucks because a lot of stuff that is well in the clear on reddit (sissy*, incest*, *dom, etc.) is potentially banned if we’re going to have a fictional consent police. While I understand the admins’ concerns, from a user perspective the current policy is already much harsher than any website I’ve ever been on that allowed porn.

    Also is it even practical/sustainable to police things like fictional consent? Reddit doesn’t not do it because they like it, they don’t do it because it’s unenforceable. Their rules are made to be unambiguous and easily applied: don’t post underage stuff (duh), no revenge porn, no deepfakes, no illegal stuff. By saying “no noncon”, this opens up so many edge cases that I don’t think that they can be ruled on fairly. Is incest noncon? Is hypno porn? What about femdom? Bondage? That one scene from Blade Runner 1982?

    • @cap
      link
      English
      41 year ago

      This is off topic to your point but lets say, hypothetically, my friend was interested in a CNC-allowed instance, would you have any recommendations?

        • Shorty
          link
          English
          11 year ago

          What do they allow and what is CNC?

          • Mikey Mongol MA
            link
            English
            71 year ago

            burgitt is one of those “unrestricted free speech” places which usually boils down to loli stuff and/or nazi stuff. I believe they are trending towards the former.

            CNC is consensual nonconsent – basically, consensual rape roleplay, though there are nuances which that description doesn’t convey.

        • @Jlissyj
          link
          English
          11 year ago

          How do I connect to it?

          • @StarNyte
            link
            English
            21 year ago

            You’ll need to go to https://burggit.moe/ and create an account there. Being defederated from this instance means you can’t access it from this account.

      • @nsfwaccount411
        link
        English
        7
        edit-2
        1 year ago

        I don’t think there is one. At least going from the fact that I don’t see many federated nsfw instances here at all, but maybe I haven’t looked hard enough.

        Tbh the legal and practical ramifications of hosting porn (particularly the borderline-legal kind) means that this is probably not going to be easy to get going for anyone living in a western country. I wouldn’t get my hopes up too much for your friend.

        EDIT: There’s not. That’s a real shame because even drawn CNC is verboten now, and I’ve had an incest caption removed today (no reason provided, but I’m assuming that since IRL incest is non-consensual by definition then it might be (partially?) verboten as a fictional kink as well).
        I know I will hold off on contributing here for now until the content policy stops getting expanded every week. I had assumed “reddit-like” rules would apply, but they’re already significantly stricter and there’s no point in submitting niche content that will get removed down the line.

        I mean, I get it from the admins’ perspective. But from a user/contributor’s perspective I really really hope they can figure out a way that we can still aggregate content that was previously allowed on reddit, else I hardly see the point of migrating.

        • @cap
          link
          English
          11 year ago

          Appreciate the thoughts/insights. I guess my friend has just gotten too used to reddit, and didn’t realize there even was legal issues around hosting porn

          • Mikey Mongol MA
            link
            English
            61 year ago

            CNC is not banned on this instance and not illegal (in the US; it may be in other countries); the problem is telling the difference between CNC and actual NC, since the whole point of CNC is to look and feel as much like noncon as possible. And then there are the grey areas of dubcon, reluctant consent, etc. It’s a real tricky space to navigate.

            • @cap
              link
              English
              1
              edit-2
              1 year ago

              Yeah of course. I guess what I’m looking for specifically is more like… cnc personals? Which seem like they’d be fine on this instance if CNC is in fact not banned (yay). I definitely agree it’s basically impossible for an outside POV to distinguish between CNC and just rape in images/video, even with filmed consent beforehand because of the whole dubcon/reluctant consent issues.

              EDIT: the original replier (OR?) to my question edited their post to confirm CNC is for sure banned here, so no yay. I might just end up staying on reddit for that, since it’s pretty advertiser unfriendly and I don’t need a mobile app since the only place I’m watching porn is at home. I’d rather deal with corporate BS on reddit than nazis on exploding heads

              EDIT2: MY FRIEND*

              • Mikey Mongol MA
                link
                English
                2
                edit-2
                1 year ago

                I can say (from conversations with the admins on Matrix) that that CNC specifically has not been completely banned. Depictions of actual noncon is banned, consensual noncon is a something that they want to keep around as long as we can find a way to clearly distinguish it from real noncon. This is all pending further discussions of the content policy, coming shortly.

      • @gaviOPM
        link
        English
        31 year ago

        It should be denoted the strict content policy currently in place is going to be discussed further at a later date. CNC will likely be a topic of discussion on how to approach that. The strict content policy right now is more or less a temporary “pause” while lemmy as a software itself improves and more tools become at our disposal.