One thing that you are missing that is super disingenuous, is the fact that YouTube premium does pay more.
But it really doesn’t, and the three other channels I linked to, who are open enough to actually show their analytics page, clearly illustrates this.
If you take a video and you send it to 1000 people who have YouTube premium, and you make another video and you send it to 1,000 people who watch ads, the video you sent to premium users will pay more.
That’s not how Premium works, though. Premium pays out based on views and time watched. Ads pay on by a) displaying ads. b) someone clicking on an ad, regardless of whether they actually watch your video for very long or not.
The major downside to Premium, however, is that larger channels can essentially monopolize on the Premium revenue, since it’s not divided up equally and is disproportionately bias towards these larger channels. Small channels (<10million subs) won’t make nearly as much from Premium as a channel like LTT.
Ads pay out differently, using quite a few variables, but it allows for even small channels to make money - way more money than Premium.
So, maybe this applies to the vast number of channels out there (i.e. the majority), but Premium doesn’t pay more than ads. For the absolute top channels (by views and hours watched), they may very well be taking the biggest piece of the pie.
From the stats that you showed, you are lumping every single person who views a video in with the small fraction of people who have YouTube premium.
That’s how YouTube counts it, and that’s the most realistic way of doing it. So few people have Premium that it wouldn’t make sense to exclude revenue generated by the vast majority of users.
I also don’t believe that you were continuing to get ads on your TV with an active YouTube premium subscription. I get 0 ads on any platform I’m signed into.
I had contacted YouTube support about those ads in early 2021, the same time that the above thread suggests these similar reports were being made, so you can believe it or not.
No, actually, even as recently as a few months back, YouTube did their own survey which showed that out of over 6000 Premium users, 21% were still seeing ads.
Really, I don’t know what or who you’re trying to defend. 🤷♂️
I’m not trying to defend anyone. Read my original post. I pay for premium because it works great for me. Lemmy users are so insufferable, trying to tell me how bad I am for paying for a service that works for me.
And yes, a Twitter poll is a great way to get data. The poll anyone can vote in, and many people DO vote just to see the results. Thanks for the very scientific and accurate data!
Read my original post. I pay for premium because it works great for me. Lemmy users are so insufferable, trying to tell me how bad I am for paying for a service that works for me.
I did. Like I said, I don’t want to prevent you for paying for something that works for you. My only comment to you was about how much content creators get from YT Premium.
And yes, a Twitter poll is a great way to get data. The poll anyone can vote in, and many people DO vote just to see the results. Thanks for the very scientific and accurate data!
It was good enough for Google, what’s the issue?
And to counter your point, the survey was only limited to Twitter users. If anything, it underreports the issue of ads being shown, since not everyone is even using Twitter or following a TeamYouTube to know about the poll, for that matter.
But, let’s say that you’re right and that a ton of people just voted randomly (which isn’t required to see the results, since the results are only revealed after the poll is over). Cut those numbers in half, and you’re still talking about 1 out of 10 Premium users seeing ads. That’s a hell of a lot more than none, even if it’s never happened to you.
Anyway. It feels like we’re beating a dead horse here. Enjoy YT Premium and the benefits it brings you, there’s really no reason to be arguing over this at all. Cheers 🍻
But it really doesn’t, and the three other channels I linked to, who are open enough to actually show their analytics page, clearly illustrates this.
That’s not how Premium works, though. Premium pays out based on views and time watched. Ads pay on by a) displaying ads. b) someone clicking on an ad, regardless of whether they actually watch your video for very long or not.
The major downside to Premium, however, is that larger channels can essentially monopolize on the Premium revenue, since it’s not divided up equally and is disproportionately bias towards these larger channels. Small channels (<10million subs) won’t make nearly as much from Premium as a channel like LTT.
Ads pay out differently, using quite a few variables, but it allows for even small channels to make money - way more money than Premium.
So, maybe this applies to the vast number of channels out there (i.e. the majority), but Premium doesn’t pay more than ads. For the absolute top channels (by views and hours watched), they may very well be taking the biggest piece of the pie.
That’s how YouTube counts it, and that’s the most realistic way of doing it. So few people have Premium that it wouldn’t make sense to exclude revenue generated by the vast majority of users.
Sigh… even YouTube staff admitted it..
I had contacted YouTube support about those ads in early 2021, the same time that the above thread suggests these similar reports were being made, so you can believe it or not.
Blud acts like YouTube premium still shows ads because of a bug from 3 years ago 💀
No, actually, even as recently as a few months back, YouTube did their own survey which showed that out of over 6000 Premium users, 21% were still seeing ads.
Really, I don’t know what or who you’re trying to defend. 🤷♂️
I’m not trying to defend anyone. Read my original post. I pay for premium because it works great for me. Lemmy users are so insufferable, trying to tell me how bad I am for paying for a service that works for me.
And yes, a Twitter poll is a great way to get data. The poll anyone can vote in, and many people DO vote just to see the results. Thanks for the very scientific and accurate data!
I did. Like I said, I don’t want to prevent you for paying for something that works for you. My only comment to you was about how much content creators get from YT Premium.
It was good enough for Google, what’s the issue?
And to counter your point, the survey was only limited to Twitter users. If anything, it underreports the issue of ads being shown, since not everyone is even using Twitter or following a TeamYouTube to know about the poll, for that matter.
But, let’s say that you’re right and that a ton of people just voted randomly (which isn’t required to see the results, since the results are only revealed after the poll is over). Cut those numbers in half, and you’re still talking about 1 out of 10 Premium users seeing ads. That’s a hell of a lot more than none, even if it’s never happened to you.
Anyway. It feels like we’re beating a dead horse here. Enjoy YT Premium and the benefits it brings you, there’s really no reason to be arguing over this at all. Cheers 🍻