• Ook the Librarian
    link
    fedilink
    11 year ago

    Perhaps you could download the entire meta study that is linked next to the abstract and go through it?

    No, I am not refereeing a paper because some commenter links it in a web forum. Why would you think that’s even close to what anyone should do in this environment?

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      11 year ago

      So let me get this straight, someone asks for a study, I provide the study of studies, which you misjudge originally for being only an abstract, and then when I correct you and tell you it’s a study, suddenly it’s not good enough. What do you actually want?

      • Ook the Librarian
        link
        fedilink
        11 year ago

        What do you actually want?

        I want conversation. Bare links are not that. Looking at the link led me to believe you providing evidence for the quack who was professing absolute safety.

        Scientifically, I agree with you. I was asking the “absolute safety” commentor to provide context to studies to lead one to that conclusion. I would have been happy to read the same from you.

        You have a lot to say for someone who is happy to slap a url down and move along. :)