• @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    5110 months ago

    That’s a good stopping point. I would like to see Children of Dune on screen too, but beyond that I think it would be difficult to successfully translate the themes of the rest of the books onto screen for a broad audience like he’s managed to do with the first one.

    • chaogomu
      link
      fedilink
      1810 months ago

      It is the full story of Paul Atreides, following the Classic story arc.

      I always point to the parallels between Dune and the Classic play Oedipus Rex.

      Oedipus was born of a family that had sinned and was punished for it by the gods. That was why Apollo issued that prophecy. Oedipus then spends the first part of his story grappling with the questions of Fate vs Free Will.

      Oedipus had his rise, and then his fall, and at that fall, he blinded himself and wandered into the wilderness.

      Paul and Oedipus. They both were bound by prophecy, and both had very little say in it.

      Oedipus’ fall was engineered from the day he was born. Paul’s… was slightly more complex.

        • chaogomu
          link
          fedilink
          410 months ago

          I’d not really link the Matrix films to Classic Greek story structure, especially not Oedipus Rex.

          I mean, Neo dies, but it’s the noble sacrifice. They sort of thing is rare in Greek story structure. Rare in the Tragedies.

          It fits some of the Heroic epics.

          Dune is a Tragedy in three parts. The Tragedy of Paul Atreides.

            • chaogomu
              link
              fedilink
              410 months ago

              I had forgotten that, mainly because it played such a minor role in the story.

              Paul and Oedipus both accept their blindness as an indication that they had always been blind. They did not see that which they should have.

              Not seeing was a major part of their fall. When they return to the story later, it’s as a blind man who finally sees, and one who offers words of advice to their child who is about to make the same mistake that they did.

              Then much later, Paul comes back as a ghola, but that part was written by Brian Hubert, who is not the best author.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      8
      edit-2
      10 months ago

      It’s been a while since I’ve seen the scifi miniseries of Children of Dune, but I remember enjoying it. First thing I saw James McAvoy in, he was pretty good.