• Nougat
    link
    fedilink
    327 months ago

    You say this as though the exact same thing doesn’t happen outside of major cities. Have you been outside?

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      English
      7
      edit-2
      7 months ago

      Lived in a small town in the country (10,000 pop) for two years and my rent was about 20% of what it was before I moved

      My country and experiences must be very different to wherever you live

      Downvotes clearly from upset people

      • @[email protected]OP
        link
        fedilink
        English
        257 months ago

        Downvotes clearly from upset people

        I love it when people edit their comments because their hot takes get downvoted but insist it’s everyone else who is upset. Ha.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          English
          3
          edit-2
          7 months ago

          I find downvotes without explanation fairly lazy, and assume they’re just triggered and/or trolling. Could be wrong though.

          • @[email protected]OP
            link
            fedilink
            English
            197 months ago

            Just because you managed to type out an opinion on the internet doesn’t mean you are entitled to other people’s time and effort.

            Not every random hot take in the comment section of The Onion community is going to be worth engaging. Particularly when the point is “cities are all shitholes so you should just leave!”

            • @[email protected]
              link
              fedilink
              English
              3
              edit-2
              7 months ago

              Yeah your reply has absolutely nothing to do with the original thread with zero counter points.

              I agree the conversation will not go anywhere, especially in this community.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        English
        187 months ago

        *Downvotes from people who are thoroughly unimpressed with your narrow viewpoint and seeming inability to empathize with other people who have very different life realities than you do.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          English
          2
          edit-2
          7 months ago

          The only other viewpoint I’ve seen from anyone countering is a hot take. So I wouldn’t be so sure

          Those other people with a “very different life” haven’t explained why they can’t do 30min drive to/from work? If they don’t want to do that I understand, but that’s a completely different conversation.

          Anyone who already drives 30mins to work is likely not renting in the centre of a major city (original comment point). Before you say because kids/family, re-read my original comment.

          So please, try telp me understand by using words

          • @[email protected]
            link
            fedilink
            English
            227 months ago

            My god, your comments are written with such a lack of empathy and your opinion is so underdeveloped that that is why you earned my downvote.

            Rent is increasing everywhere because inflation is increasing everywhere, including outside of major cities.

            More importantly, the solution to "housing is increasingly controlled by those who own a lot of housing and they are using that control to extract more wealth from those who own less than them. " is not simply “move somewhere less densely populated, the housing there is cheaper”. Why? Because of course it’s fucking not.

            Housing is cheaper there because less people live there. What does that mean? Less people want to live there, for a myriad of reasons. Maybe I have multiple family members within a city? Hell, I have friends certainly and they’re not moving with me - decade long friendships that won’t go away but I’ll certainly see far far less.

            Maybe I have kids and I don’t want to move them to a new school? Maybe the schools in my neighboring small towns aren’t properly funded or have a conservative board so their education is skewed.

            Maybe I like going to IMAX theaters as a treat and my neighboring towns don’t have one. Or ice skating or to an arcade or to top golf or to a Thai boxing club or to a pottery class. Cities have these experiences in spades, and maybe my neighboring towns dont.

            Maybe I hate driving and commuting would not only cost more of my most valuable resource but it would cause things I’m opposed to like increased pollution while costing me more money and increasing my risk of accidental harm. Maybe the city I would have to commute in our through has such a reliance on car infrastructure that everywhere is clogged up with traffic most hours of the day making any sort of timely transit impossible.

            Maybe I just like good food, smaller towns have less variety, less options, and fewer hours. Maybe I like well sourced meats like fish, which my small towns struggle to source.

            Maybe my neighboring towns don’t speak my language as well as cities, they can’t accommodate me while I learn the native language. Maybe I like a racially diverse populace with high education and who have a multitude of life experiences. Maybe I’m LGBTQ and my neighboring towns are too conservative to treat me well. Maybe violent crime is higher in the suburbs and neighboring towns and that worries me.

            I mean, you’ve clearly thought about all of this and found it inconsequential when compared to hundreds of dollars in rent. But I’d be willing to pay more money to stay in a public transit heavy city, with my friends, so I can get good sushi and Turkish food when I want, and see movies on the big screen.

            That doesnt mean I want to pay some guy’s 4th mortgage at a rate that costs me my ability to ever own an apartment. Housing is a right, we have the capacity to make it affordable everywhere, we should be doing things that improve everyone’s lives not pretending that it’s acceptable to tell everyone to uproot their entire life in exchange for €X00 a month back.

          • @[email protected]
            link
            fedilink
            English
            27 months ago

            Not everyone can drive. Many households only have one car between multiple adults. Some can’t afford childcare and rely on nearby relatives to help out, and would have to start paying for childcare if they moved. Some people don’t have the education or job training that would allow them to get a job worth commuting to. Some people are reliant on social services or medical care that is not available otherwise. Many of the suburbs around American cities are just as expensive as the cities themselves but without walkable areas, nearby shops, or any public transportation.

            This is just a handful of examples and it barely scratches the surface of the more complicated issues at hand here

      • Nougat
        link
        fedilink
        137 months ago

        That’s because – wait for it – the cost of living is lower in small towns. Not just rent, but everything, is cheaper. And there are far fewer job opportunities in small towns, especially if you’re in a specialized or highly trained field.

        You know what else is real easy to find in small towns in the country? Corruption, nepotism, racism, wage theft. Pretty much any way for the big fish in the little pond to keep their thumbs on the scale is easy, because there’s so few people to call attention to it, and no real incentive for the state to get involved to clean things up.

        Maybe that was working in your favor.