• @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    16 months ago

    That’s a terrible argument. That was one pharaoh and the monument would have been finished within his lifetime

    That’s two pharaohs and the mega-monuments completed over 27 years that Ramses lived to see were the exception rather than the rule.

    And, again, I was talking about the Jesus of the Bible

    The Gospel of Mark is part of the Bible. That makes Jesus at least as historical as anyone in Herodotus’s Histories. Significantly more so in many respects, as Herodotus writes on The Trojan War, some 800 years before his birth.

    If there was a real Jesus, we have absolutely no idea what, if anything, said about him in the Bible actually happened or was something we said because there is no evidence of it outside the Bible

    You could say the same of the Anatolian tribes or the Achaemenid dynasty or Sparta.

    there is no real physical proof that Jesus Christ ever existed

    Go back far enough and there is vanishingly little biographical evidence that any singular person existed. From the Mayan Empire to the Australian Aboriginal People, you can wave your hands and dismiss them all, due to the lack of first party written accounts of their existence.

    • Flying Squid
      link
      fedilink
      26 months ago

      Herodotus got a lot of things wrong and said a lot of things that were false- unless you think giant golden ants really used to live in Persia.

      https://listverse.com/2015/04/08/10-historical-facts-that-herodotus-got-hilariously-wrong/

      There is a reason Herodotus is known both as the Father of History and the Father of Lies.

      So bringing him into an argument about whether or not a character in a book with magical powers exists when the person you’re talking to says that the textual claims aren’t reliable is beyond me.

      And you are still ignoring my argument, an argument where I never claimed there was no historical person the character of Jesus in the Bible was based upon, so I’m not sure there is any point to continuing this conversation.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        26 months ago

        Herodotus got a lot of things wrong

        Show me the first hand written account from the period that refutes him.