• Admiral Patrick
    link
    fedilink
    English
    192
    edit-2
    1 month ago

    I think it’s more a generational gap in basic computer skills.

    Millennials grew up alongside modern computing (meaning the two matured together). We dealt with everything from BASIC on a C64 to DOS and then through Windows 3 through current. We also grew up alongside Linux. We understand computers (mostly) and the (various) paradigms they use.

    Gen Z is what I refer to as the iPad generation (give or take a few years). Everything’s dumbed down and they never had to learn what a folder is or why you should organize documents into them instead of throwing them all in “Documents” library and just using search. (i.e. throw everything in a junk drawer and rummage through it as needed).

    As with millennials who can’t balance a checkbook or do basic household tasks, I don’t blame Gen Z for not learning; I blame those who didn’t teach them. In this case, tech companies who keep dumbing everything down.

    Edit: “Balance a checkbook” doesn’t have to mean a physical transaction log for old school checks. It just means keeping track of expenditures and deposits so that you know the money in your account is sufficient to cover your purchases. You’d be surprised how many people my age can’t manage that.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      English
      831 month ago

      you should organize documents into them instead of throwing them all in “Documents” library and just using search.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          English
          171 month ago

          Organizing my downloads has been on my to do list for… Four, I think? Yeah, four… phones…

          • @[email protected]
            link
            fedilink
            English
            31 month ago

            Aren’t most (sensible) data hoarders very organized? You want to save shit and be able to find it later lol

            • jlow (he/him)
              link
              fedilink
              English
              11 month ago

              Yeah, but downloading new stuff is even more exciting then sorting the already downloaded stuff 😸

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          English
          11 month ago

          I’ve been interested in Zettelkasten for a few years, since I discovered Obsidian, but I’ve never been able to quite get the hang of it enough to make it stick

          • @[email protected]
            link
            fedilink
            English
            3
            edit-2
            1 month ago

            Obsidian user as well. I like to think of it that tags are folders.

            When you put something in a folder, you have to choose one of the files identities. Tags more or less allow you to assign a file to any number of groups.

            So if you’re writing about an NPC in a DnD campaign, for example: That NPC will exist in a certain place. He will be associated with particular guilds and he will have certain moves that you might want to keep track of. You can later easily search by a guild or a move or a place and there will be a link to that NPC and others that share those indentifying characteristics.

            A big advantage of zettelkasten is that you don’t need to really worry about file management in the sense of needing to make exclusionary choices.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      English
      47
      edit-2
      1 month ago

      Millennials grew up alongside modern computing (meaning the two matured together). We dealt with everything from BASIC on a C64 to DOS and then through Windows 3 through current. We also grew up alongside Linux

      Only the oldest millenials did. When the youngest were born, the internet and Windows 95 were readily available and they were in middle school when the iPhone came out.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        English
        4
        edit-2
        1 month ago

        Yea, I’m a millenial, and I remember mostly only interacting with old Macintosh LCs in elementary school, and then Windows 95 and up after that. My uncle had an old Tandy computer running DOS, that I remember at least learning how to run a game on, but by the time I was interacting with a computer, regularly, Windows 95 and AOL were the most common thing.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          English
          21 month ago

          We did have some DOS games on CD during the Windows 95/98 era, though. Lemmings always ran better if you dropped down to DOS and ran it from there instead of trying to run it through Windows, for instance.

    • classic
      link
      fedilink
      451 month ago

      I appreciate this measured take. Whenever generational differences get brought up, they oftentimes seemed framed as if generations are biologically different creatures or willfully choosing to be stupid in some sector. In all, or at least must cases, it’s what you suggest: people responding and developing based on what the environment has presented them.

    • Björn Tantau
      link
      fedilink
      English
      291 month ago

      Trouble is that there are enough millennials who also have absolutely no clue about computers. Between dude-bros who won’t touch that nerd shit and girls who got told by their nerd boyfriend’s that the computer will start to burn if they click anything besides their allowed icons a vast majority of people are glad if they know how to turn on the computer and print out their document.

      Yes, there are probably a lot more computer literate millennials than in other generations. But even there it pretty much depends on family and friends. And in a pirate community on Lemmy most of the people will belong to the tech savvy bubble.

      In our friend group even the most computer illiterate kid knew how to set up a LAN without a DHCP server. Their younger siblings had no idea a LAN was even a thing.

      My wife’s ex always told her that she couldn’t understand how to work with a computer. Her older brother who works in IT wouldn’t explain anything to her either. They were pretty astonished when they heard that she had installed a GPU by herself (which most people here know is trivial). Which gave her enough confidence to fix her VCR by herself.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        English
        251 month ago

        They were pretty astonished when they heard that she had installed a GPU by herself (which most people here know is trivial). Which gave her enough confidence to fix her VCR by herself.

        Anyone can learn any skill if they actually invest the time.

        And regarding the older brother, you learn pretty quickly working help desk that users generally don’t care what the problem is or why it happened. They just want to get back to work and not have it happen again. After a while you get conditioned to just be friendly and solve the issue without explaining what you’re doing or why.

    • Tar_Alcaran
      link
      fedilink
      English
      231 month ago

      Exactly. Basically nobody in their 30s can, say, drive a manual car without a synchro, unless they specifically practiced it, because there is zero need to learn that skill. And basically nobody under 20 can set port forwarding on a router because there is basically zero need for that skill.

      When I wanted sound on Arkanoid, I HAD to learn IRQ settings, so I did. But now that stuff just works.

      • Kaity
        link
        fedilink
        English
        21 month ago

        I’m a zillenial that had a manual that blew its clutch while I was out and I had to relearn how to drive it back home, that was scaryfun. Where does that put me?

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          English
          21 month ago

          Adventurous young person, ready to be sent on a quest, is where you got filed in my head.

          Sincerely,
          ~Lazy millenial wizard who wants help running errands.

          • Kaity
            link
            fedilink
            English
            21 month ago

            Flattered to be called young but I am definitely entering my own lazy era :)

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        English
        11 month ago

        And basically nobody under 20 can set port forwarding on a router because there is basically zero need for that skill.

        Torrenting, online gaming and self-hosting ain’t dead.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      English
      201 month ago

      This is part of why I, who am part of Gen Z, am actually really thankful that I didn’t get access to iPad until 9 (first gen, it might still be around here somewhere, kinda wonder if it’ll ever become a relic) and phone until 13, but did have access to a super old windows computer. It taught me how to install mods in Minecraft. It was astronomically difficult for me at that time with my limited understanding and all the fake green “Download here!” buttons that kept duping me and installing tons of bloatware and even malware onto the PC (yet another reason why AdBlock is a privacy and security concern, honestly deadass don’t let kids use a computer without it). But eventually I caught on and got good at identifying the scams from a young age and was able to teach other kids, and even eventually got into command stuff and writing my own mods. I memorized all of the block and item IDs before the flattening, but after that I was so disheartened that all my memorization was useless I kinda just stopped and never got really good at it. But still, just from that alone my computer knowledge was way ahead of other people’s around that time, and you might even say it set the foundation for my now linux-using open-source-contributing fediverse-loving self hahaha

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        English
        61 month ago

        Honestly I should have a bit of respect for zeds and alphas who grow up around locked black boxes and still despite that manage to come out the other side knowing how to use something like terminal or git.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      English
      161 month ago

      I don’t know how many time I answered the same thing to the exact same argument but here goes:

      In short, it’s most likely not true. You’re implying the the millennials were generally more competent but it’s very likely wrong, the vast majority of people in that gen had absolutely no clue what they were doing on a computer most of the time they just knew how to do a few limited things with them.

      The apps didn’t make the masses tech illiterate, the app adjusted to the existing ones and removed the stuff they couldn’t never understand, like where to save a file to be able to find it later. (I’ve worked in a support call center and I can tell you with 98.5% accuracy that the lost file is in system32).

      The gen-z has quite a lot of smart, curious tech savvy people, and a vast majority of tech-illiterate people, so did the millenial, and the X, and the boomers.

      This whole generational superiority argument is just as baseless as it was when my gen was blaming yours for being lazy, not able to learn anything due to a short attention span and an obsession for brunch and avocado toast.

      • Snot Flickerman
        link
        fedilink
        English
        8
        edit-2
        1 month ago

        Personally, I think both of these perspectives have truth to them but neither is the whole story.

        True, there are tech savvy people in every generation, and the majority of each generation isn’t necessarily tech savvy.

        But it’s also true that the tech savvy people today are growing up in a world where technology has been obfuscated and simplified whereas formerly tech savvy people didn’t have a choice but to learn the ropes to be involved at all, which meant there was more need for Millennial tech savvy people to understand the basics, while there is no such equivalent need for Gen Z.

        I agree, I think many are overselling the impact of that, but it has an impact nonetheless, however small.

        I know this is true or I wouldn’t have such trouble explaining to crypto (specifically NFT) enthusiasts why counting bits matters and how there is limited “space” inside an NFT for nothing but a simple URL. If you grew up in the 80’s or 90’s and were learning ANY amount of networking, counting bits for subnets in IPv4 was pretty much a requirement. Now a lot of networking is obfuscated and automated with IPv6, which is finally coming into its own, and a side effect is that understanding these limitations of the technology has flown out the window for buzzwords like “smart contracts.”

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          English
          21 month ago

          You make the same mistake as the previous person. You take the exemple of the minority of people who cared to try to understand how computer worked and generalize it to the entire gen.

          I have thousands of people in my office that prove everyday that millenial are for the most part tech illiterate and do not care about how thing works. I’ve seen the millenial arrive in the work env and the gen-z and there is absolutely no difference. Millenial were exactly as dumb (or as smart). If anything, I think gen-z are actually smarter because they come in not believing the corporate bullshit the X and the Y drank like cool-aid. But that’s another topic.

          In any case, all the stuff we had to go through didn’t make us smarter, for every 10,000 of people of my gen who learned they had to edit autoexec.bat to launch a game, I’d bet that barely one knew what the heck himem.sys actually was. That didn’t make them smarter, just monkeys who learned a trick.

          So yeah, geeky gen-Z don’t need to tweak as many parameters, they can directly launch fusion 360 and start designing parts for their 3D printers. Tech has moved on. Gen-Z geeks fiddle with other stuff than shitty windows drivers.

      • socsa
        link
        fedilink
        71 month ago

        I actually hire engineers and I do notice that the zoomers seem to have less general computing and IT skills, though I think some of that has to do with how the curriculum has changed. Software engineering and CS is just way more specialized than it used to be and isn’t just a slow evolution from computer engineering these days. So you don’t get that broad computing background which starts with electrodynamics and works up through digital design, comms, networking, and ultimately software.

        For my purposes, this knowledge is a big part of what differentiates a developer from an engineer (and proper computer science is a different thing entirely) which has made it really difficult to figure out what to expect from a software engineering degree.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          English
          11 month ago

          Oh don’t get me started on modern “CS” curriculum of some schools, it’s atrocious. I see them start learning about react and nodejs in year 1 because “that’s what companies need” but that leaves them with massive fundamental knowledge gaps. I’ve seen people 5 years in their degree who struggled with Boolean logic.

          I believe they should start at the bottom of the stack and climb up instead of starting somewhere at the top and being left oblivious about the massive amount of stuff going on below. And the “internship” system we have in my country is massive BS. Basically instead of learning they spend 1/2 of their education time doing menial job in companies. Which means their 5 years degrees is barely 2.5 of actual school time but we still like to pretend it’s equivalent to a normal masters degree.

          The “need of the industry” for “IT people” has lead to the proliferation of diploma mill curriculum that churn out monkeys lightly trained on the proverbial typewriter and calls them “software engineers”.

          But we still have excellent schools that produce very well trained people, and I do not believe they produce less of them, it’s just that we also produce a lot more that went through bad curriculums.

      • Aatube
        link
        fedilink
        51 month ago

        How do I delete this useless, obtuse, and inaccessible folder so I never lose my files again‽

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          English
          11 month ago

          Press and hold the Windows key, then tap the R. Let go of the windows key. Type cmd enter. Type format C:\ enter.

          Sadly they “fixed” this.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        English
        31 month ago

        I’m sorry, but you’re wrong. Relying on edge cases in either generation is pointless. Millenials had zero tech support to help them for everything you need to do on computers.

        How to load a program: Nowadays - touch the icon on the screen. Millenials - Load"$“,8 LIST LOAD"LEISURESUIT*”,8,1 (wait 10 min.) RUN

        How to install a game: Nowadays - Click BUY on game store and choose INSTALL. Millenials - Learn MSDOS basics, Type a series of 5 commands without typos

        How to configure game settings: Nowadays - Play with volume sliders, Graphics preferences, and game difficulty. Millenials - Edit config.sys or autoexec.bat to ensure device drivers are loaded, load game, assign proper IRQ, DMA variables to get your SOUNDBLASTER card to play sound, select game difficulty

        How to setup a printer: Nowadays - go to manufacturers website and download drivers, run setup.exe, plug in printer to USB port. Millenials - Check Device manager in Windows to determine COM port and other relevant variables. Set values in word processing software. Employ Minor in mechanical engineering to align or correct bad ink ribbon with perforated track runners. Repeat fixes every 5 pages ad nauseum.

        All that BS and more required hours of research to learn how to do in an era where guidance was buried in some sketchy newsgroup where ‘Rick Rolling’ was seeing if you’d notice “Deltree c:” in the instructions, and not just a simple 20 second video on TikTok.

        I work with children using Ipads and that one kid who doesn’t get lost if the relevant icon is missing in the UI is the one I know is going to be trouble. They say average IQ increases by 3 every generation and this is the first one I don’t think that trend will hold for because they aren’t required to think at all ever.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          English
          31 month ago

          Having to search out codecs even, that was a big thing back in the day. My entire school was passing around videos on floppies an cds and learning about codecs to play the Pamela Anderson tape it seemed like. Years after it was on vhs I think

        • DefederateLemmyMl
          link
          fedilink
          English
          11 month ago

          Millenials - Load"$“,8 LIST LOAD"LEISURESUIT*”,8,1 (wait 10 min.) RUN

          Even the oldest millennials were just toddlers when the C64 was relevant, so this is not a typical millennial experience at all. It’s really a GenX thing… so once again we are forgotten.

          I would say millennials’ computer experience starts in the late DOS/Win3.11 era at the very earliest, but more typically in the Windows 9x and early XP era. So even IRQ/DMA/config.sys/autoexec.bat fuckery is not that typical.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      English
      81 month ago

      I think your first paragraph only applies to US or US-like countries. I learned how to navigate unregulated Internet to download most things I could fit, and then expanded into more technical knowledge as I grew up. I know of the things you said in your first paragraph now, but I did not grow up beside them to have learned what I know today, or even what I knew back then. These computers were expensive (for us?) at first, so very few people had them, and then a few years later they were more abundant and easier for us to even have a chance to learn about them.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      English
      71 month ago

      Your analysis fits neatly into what the book Because Internet describes as different waves of “internet people”. First were geeks who went there before it was mainstream, second us millennials growing up as it is getting mainstream, alongside older folks forced to use it at work or voluntarily at home. Third wave are GenZ growing up when everything is easy already and, ironically, also even older folks now that it’s accessible for them.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      English
      61 month ago

      You say that like other generations don’t also just save everything to the desktop.

      It’s not about generations at all. Some people who grew up with early computers may have used them but never really “got it”.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      English
      51 month ago

      Almost like the education system was meant as a long term investment to turn out a profit instead of “education”

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      English
      41 month ago

      Who owns a checkbook? I also didn’t need to learn cursive, or how to take care of a horse. If you want to learn something you will.

      • Admiral Patrick
        link
        fedilink
        English
        151 month ago

        “Balance a checkbook” doesn’t have to mean a physical transaction log. It just means keeping track of expenditures and deposits so that you know the money in your account is sufficient to cover your purchases. You’d be surprised how many people my age can’t manage that. Also, at first, I read that as “Who owns a Chromebook?” lol.

        Outside of using cursive for my signature, yeah, I’ve never used it in real life.

        If you want to learn something you will.

        True, but we learned computing because we had to.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          English
          11 month ago

          You don’t learn to drive in a round about, or use the automatic checkout, or a thousand other things that have changed…

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        English
        61 month ago

        By the time I was born, checks weren’t in regular use here anymore. I’ve never seen one in real life. I’m 27

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          English
          41 month ago

          You probably do not know b/c reddthat has downvotes disabled, but people are downvoting your comment.

          I find it the height of irony that your comment, which is relevant and contributes to the conversation, is receiving the “*I* personally do not like this idea” treatment.

          A comment that aims to provide a more balanced perspective, to round out the discussion beyond “things should be the way that I am most comfortable with”, and offering not only logical facts but very relevant personal experience.

          Reddit Lemmy can be so toxic sometimes. :-|

          • @[email protected]
            link
            fedilink
            English
            61 month ago

            I like the lack of downvotes, it’s nice. I get to focus on arguments being made. If someone wants to tell me they disagree, they’re going to have to actually tell me

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      English
      21 month ago

      Gen X: don’t quote the ancient piracy to me, Millennial. I was there for BBS and Napster.

    • kratoz29
      link
      fedilink
      English
      11 month ago

      I can take that argument but also, how is that people is that unaware of how to do these kinds of process, many of those people study or work in something that relates with tech, are you telling me it is just because they didn’t learn of use it in their earlier days?

      Also, it is way easier to pirate nowadays than before, that evolved too you know?

      I’d say the biggest culprit is laziness… Or entitlement.

    • Fonzie!
      link
      fedilink
      English
      122 days ago

      Millenials grew up using BASIC on Windows 3?!

      Millenials were teenagers possibly learning coding starting from 1995, the world was using C++ on Windows 95 at best.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      English
      11 month ago

      Born in late ‘80, I’m borderline. A Xennial, I guess.

      Just yesterday I was groping on Mastodon that so much of Linux is done via the command line, which messes me up because I’ve only ever really used OSs with a GUI. Sure, we had a family C64, but my brother would load the games for me. Then we got a ‘proper’ Windows PC, where I stayed until I got my first Mac in ‘07.

      I’m not unfamiliar with doing stuff in Terminal, but all I really do is follow instructions I find online.

      • Kaity
        link
        fedilink
        English
        11 month ago

        I mean that is usually all it takes, and as time passes you learn, provided you have the will to do exactly what you are doing and you have an interest in understanding it.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        English
        1
        edit-2
        1 month ago

        You must have big hands if you can grope a mastodon!

        (In all seriousness youtube “command line basics” or “bash basics” and follow along with a video or two like it’s a class, helped me when I ditched windows.)