• Cethin
    link
    fedilink
    English
    1020 days ago

    They addressed the elephant issue in their comment. I recommend you read it again. The summary is elephants evolved without predation, so they don’t bread in large numbers. Prey animals breed with the assumption a not-insignificant portion of their population will die prematurely due to predation. If this doesn’t happen then their population balloons until it consumes all available resources, then it collapses.

    This happens fairly frequently where we’ve removed predators from the ecosystem. Its why we promote deer hunting, for example. We’ve removed their natural predators, and if they aren’t culled then they will grow until they collapse. This is well understood and not controversial.

    I guess we could engineer the planet until this isn’t an issue, but that’ll take a few millenia and probably isn’t the best idea. Let nature be natural. It’d be fascist to assume it’s our domain to conquer and dominate into submission.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      -920 days ago

      elephants evolved without predation

      Really? They just jumped from rabbit-sized mammals to elephant-size with zero predation?

      Prey animals breed with the assumption

      This is the first time I’ve heard of a deer “assuming” anything.

      If this doesn’t happen then their population balloons until it consumes all available resources, then it collapses.

      Evolution doesn’t stop simply because predation stops. Yes, deer population will expand if predation stops, but that expansion will not result in some “Reindeer Apocalypse” as the colonialist brain-trust on here is trying to pretend it would. No, it will not result in the consumption of all available resources, as reindeer’s natural environment is vast frikken northern hemisphere continents. If that could be possible, you might as well try to prove that bison hoovered up all the world’s grasslands before humans even managed to become humans.

      Let nature be natural.

      We closed that door permanently about two centuries ago. We did…

      We’ve removed their natural predators,

      …this, remember?

      It’d be fascist to assume it’s our domain to conquer and dominate into submission.

      I’d say it’s pretty eco-fash to assume that this isn’t the exact thing we’ve already done.