Hundreds of thousands of Palestinians have been displaced across Gaza due to Israel’s air raids after Hamas’s attack.
  • mwguy@infosec.pubEnglish
    22·
    2 years ago

    I am loathe to defend hamas, but the UN stats just don’t portray them as the aggressors.

    Mr Dog muffins, if the Aboriginals in Australia started a campaign of war against the white Austrailians, what makes you think the casualty numbers would be less skewed there?

    If Australian aboriginals started terrorising the rest of us, of course we would use reasonable force to bring that to a stop. If we decided that peaceful solutions had been exhausted,

    Well congrats now you’re doing the same thing Israel is doing. Peaceful solutions with Hamas have been exhausted.

    I can assure you other countries wouldn’t be sending us billions of dollars worth of hardware with which to exterminate them.

    How would you feel if we sent billions of dollars of Aid to the people trying to genocide you instead? What if we continued to commit billions in aid in the form of materials we knew were being used to create weapons to indiscriminately kill Australians. And then we condemned you for trying to stop that miltilitary aid?

    The good news is, for countries like ours; we don’t have to pretend to sit up on our high horse like the Europeans do. We have complicated, often evil histories with our colonized populations. But as much as we can and should call out that history as evil, as genocide; we should also know that you can’t answer a genocide with genocide.

    • DogMuffins@discuss.tchncs.deEnglish
      2·
      2 years ago

      Those stats aren’t from war-time - this isn’t a spears vs guns situation. Sorry maye you’re welcome to criticise me all you like for Australia’s treatment of first nations people but your aboriginal metaphor is not analogous to the gaza conflict and isn’t helping illustrate your point.

      The core of our disagreement is the level of force used in response.

      Forgive me, but I’ve come to expect a “fucked around and found out” mode of diplomacy from the US. As in, hamas threw the first punch so theres a moral imperative to grind gaza into the dust.

      I don’t see it that way. A few weeks ago there was a stale mate. Israel has adequate defences. Securing Israel with minimal loss of life ought to be the priority.

      I’m happy to disagree in this regard, neither of us are going to change our positions.

      • mwguy@infosec.pubEnglish
        11·
        2 years ago

        Those stats aren’t from war-time - this isn’t a spears vs guns situation.

        That’s objectively wrong. There were several active conflicts during that time period. With similar targeted bombing campaigns, in 2008-2009, 2012 and 2014 with several smaller skirmishes in between.