Important clarification/FAQ

I am not calling to coddle or excuse the behavior of bigoted men in any way!

I am calling to be kind and understanding to young men (often ages 10-20) who are very manipulable and succeptible to the massive anti feminist propaganda machine. Hope this clarifies that very important distinction. :)

Very good comments that express key points:

Edit: This post has now been removed and restored twice. I want to encourage you all:

Be decent to one another

I think this post is a valuable thing given the current state of the Fediverse, please don’t fuck it up for us by being toxic in the comments.

  • Bonehead
    link
    fedilink
    18
    edit-2
    6 months ago

    This whole thing is completely blown out of proportion. The fact that young disenfranchised men are getting upset that women they don’t know are choosing a bear over them says that they are taking it personally when it’s not.

    If you’re a young man, and the people around you have decided they would rather choose the bear over you, that’s a sign that you need to sit down and take a hard look at yourself about why they would do that. What have you done that would make them decide that. And if you extend that feeling to random women that you don’t know, then you need to sit down and take a hard look at yourself why you feel that way. You don’t know the lived experience of random women. You don’t know why they would choose certain death over you. Taking it personally only shows your immaturity. You can’t control how other people feel. You can only control yourself. If you want to understand why women around you would choose the bear, maybe try asking them nicely and actually listen. Empathy works both ways. Showing some will encourage people to reciprocate.

      • Bonehead
        link
        fedilink
        96 months ago

        Way to purposely misinterpret what I said.

        How are women “wrong” about feeling uncomfortable around unknown men? How are women asking you to fix that problem? None of what you just said is actually happening. Stop creating a fantasy where you’re perfect and it’s everyone else who has a problem.

          • Bonehead
            link
            fedilink
            46 months ago

            That’s fine. No one is forcing you to be around unknown women. And those women aren’t going to be offended that you don’t want to be around them. Those woman aren’t going to call you completely irrational for choosing not to be around them. Those women aren’t going to demand that you empathize with them. You are free to feel however you want.

              • Bonehead
                link
                fedilink
                36 months ago

                Then why is this post filled with men upset that unknown women don’t want to be alone with them?

                • @[email protected]
                  link
                  fedilink
                  56 months ago

                  You tell me. People aren’t forced to be around unknown people. Ever. According to you.

                  I’m sure those unknown women would think I’m silly for just wanting to be in a room with people who aren’t going to sexually harass me.

                  • Bonehead
                    link
                    fedilink
                    36 months ago

                    I’m sure those unknown women would think I’m silly for just wanting to be in a room with people who aren’t going to sexually harass me.

                    Why would anyone do that? No one wants to be sexually harassed. That’s the point women are trying to make. They don’t want to be sexually harassed either, that’s why they are choosing the bear.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      86 months ago

      It’s not certain death. Bears are predictable, you can easily scare a bear away or play dead. Random men are unpredictable. As a man, I would much rather ruin into a beat than some sketchy dude who wants to rob me or wear my skin as a coat.

      • Bonehead
        link
        fedilink
        126 months ago

        But that’s just it. It’s not about the bear. It was never about the bear. It’s about women not trusting unknown men, and the men who get offended by that. Anyone that insists on predicting what the bear would do, or wants to discuss statistics of bear attacks, is missing the point. It’s distracting away from the actual conversation.

        Women have the right to feel uncomfortable around unknown men. Men have the right to feel hurt by that sentiment. But it’s not the responsibility of women to coddle the men and make them feel better. The men need to understand that they can only control themselves. Part of controlling themselves is to empathize with women and try to understand why they would choose the bear. Not get upset that a random woman doesn’t want to be alone with them. Not proclaim they’d also choose the bear because they don’t want to be alone with some sketchy man. Not convince them that the bear is statistically more dangerous. Just simply listen and try to understand. That’s all. When you learn to control yourself and empathize, you’ll find others that will do the same. And then maybe some of those women will choose you over the bear…

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      2
      edit-2
      6 months ago

      That would be cool and all if women reciprocated and listened to men for once.

      One of the ways in which some men radicalize is through support towards women that is not appreciated nor reciprocated. Something like “duh, if you didn’t support us we’d call you the problem”.

      Of course this gets personal. If women expect men to listen, could they please listen for once? I’m sure they’d get a lot of insights behind a lot of male behaviors, and particularly why we are upset and why some men turn aggressive and hostile and follow rapists and douchebags.

      Want insights on abusive behaviors and how to prevent them? The answers are there. Heck, threads under this post contain the true answers. Listen.

      • Bonehead
        link
        fedilink
        46 months ago

        You are not owed reciprocation. You are not owed appreciation. No one is asking you to listen to them. You’ve taken it upon yourself to respond to a woman making a general statement that’s not directed at you. You made that choice.

        It’s not the responsibility of women to ensure that you do not become radicalized. You have to take ownership of your own life and the choices that you make. That includes the choice to become aggressive, or hostile, or to become a rapist. Women don’t make you do those things. You decide to do those things, no matter how you try to justify it. The choice is yours alone.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          3
          edit-2
          6 months ago

          And women are not owed being listened to and cared for, exactly.

          We do it not because we owe something to each other, but because we’re empathetic human beings able to listen and care for the discourse that is not about us. But we too have something to say, and it is directly relevant to the substance of the conversation.

          And it gets more and more frustrating to see many women venting their anger without actually trying to listen up and see the other side of their story, gaining insights that are useful in combating the very issue they complain about. The solutions are there. It’s just that no one actually cares for them.

          Nothing good comes from a discourse when one relevant side is shushed every time they speak up. And this is the case.

          Now, what is more important to you - venting anger and shifting blame? Or listening in search of insights?

          • Bonehead
            link
            fedilink
            36 months ago

            You want someone to listen to you? You want “respect”? You have to give it first. That’s how life works. You can either go around being respectful to other people, and if it’s reciprocated then great but if not then you move on. Or you can go around being disrespectful to everyone until you get respect first, and people will rightfully treat you the same way.

            Women are not venting to you. They are just venting. You are choosing to inject yourself into the conversation and demand that they listen to you first. You’re demanding that they accept your solutions without question. And then you wonder why no one wants to listen to you. If you’re unwilling to see that, that’s your problem.

            • @[email protected]
              link
              fedilink
              1
              edit-2
              6 months ago

              And that’s what men in the feminist conversations normally do - listen and care and respect. I am no exception. (By the way, the reciprocity on that barely ever comes, but that’s a topic for another conversation)

              But this post isn’t just a vent. Would it be correct for me to publicly ask: “would you rather be alone in a forest with a bear or a black person”?

              Those questions contain a simple subtext, a comparison of men to dangerous animals, irrespective of any nuance, which is a form of attack on a social group. And I doubt someone just got interested in stats on what women would choose. This is an act of, at best, rude behavior, and at worst, an active hostility, and men see it as such.

              This is not a singular case by any means, and it continuously reiterates in one form or the other.

              And that’s where we have to interject.

              • Bonehead
                link
                fedilink
                46 months ago

                would you rather be alone in a forest with a bear or a black person”

                Stop comparing yourself to black men. This isn’t about race.

                And that’s what men in the feminist conversations normally do - listen and care and respect. I am no exception.

                Yeah, except…

                If women expect men to listen, could they please listen for once?

                You don’t want to listen. You’re just waiting for your turn to talk.

                a comparison of men to dangerous animals, irrespective of any nuance, which is a form of attack on a social group.

                Again, you are purposely putting yourself in that group and getting offended by it. You are not being oppressed just because someone who doesn’t even know you exist would rather not be alone with you.

                And that’s where we have to interject.

                Which is why women are choosing the bear. Unfortunately you don’t seem to get that. You don’t have to interject, because it’s not about you.

                • @[email protected]
                  link
                  fedilink
                  1
                  edit-2
                  6 months ago

                  Why should I not compare? Both are immutable traits people are born with, and both may serve as a basis for discrimination.

                  The single time men massively interject to stand up for themselves is immediately claimed as a hostile hijacking and an unwillingness to listen.

                  No, we do listen. But that doesn’t mean we will seal our mouths when we are blatantly attacked.

                  Purposefully putting myself to what group? Memes? This is not some obscure radfem space, this is a general purpose Internet place. And what’s happening here is not okay.

                  • Bonehead
                    link
                    fedilink
                    3
                    edit-2
                    6 months ago

                    Why should I not compare?

                    Because there is no difference between a white man and black man. On average, they are physically similar. But there is a massive physical difference between men and women. And before you interject with “ackshually, women can rape men too.” No one is disputing that. But how it is done and how often it happens is vastly different. Violent rape is a legitimate concern for every single woman, whether you want to accept it or not.

                    Purposefully putting myself to what group?

                    a comparison of men to dangerous animals, irrespective of any nuance, which is a form of attack on a social group.

                    I literally pointed out what group I was referring to.

                    You claim that you’re willing to listen, but you insist that women listen to you and accept your solutions without question. You claim you’re being attacked, when women are asked the question on camera without directing it at any specific person. You claim women are wrong to feel that way, without ever asking why they feel that way and what experiences lead to that decision. You claim you’re standing up for yourself, against women that would choose to be alone with a bear rather than a random unknown man.

                    No one wants your solutions. No one asked for your solutions. No one is attacking you, because no one even knows who you are. No woman is wrong for feeling anything. And no woman should be forced to choose any man are not comfortable with, even if you’re a “nice guy”. It’s not about you…

          • @[email protected]
            link
            fedilink
            26 months ago

            Nothing good comes from a discourse when one relevant side is shushed every time they speak up. And this is the case.

            I mean I think it’s a pretty mutual like, set of actions that happens as a result of the initial framing of the conversation being like a stupid absurd obvious ragebait hypothetical more than like, a systematic failing in our society. Or, rather, I think the systematic failing of society is that these conversations are only allowed to come about, to blow up, out of those sorts of bad faith framings, rather than happening more naturally on even ground. I think that’s the root cause, which I think affects both people groups, rather than it just being like a cultural failing that you might attribute to. I dunno, something else, something not as good as that.

            • @[email protected]
              link
              fedilink
              16 months ago

              Undoubtedly, the original hypothetical is a ragebait - but it truly succeeds at forming people’s opinions, which is something that can’t be ignored when groups of people are attacked.

              I’d much rather not have those hypotheticals at all, indeed, and have neutral and positive talks.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        36 months ago

        If all women listened to men for once?

        Someone come out and tell me I’m on a Poe’s law hidden camera show.