Copper sulphate is a listed “organic” fungicide despite not having any carbon atoms.
I’ve seen “Organic” salt.
that doesn’t have Carbon, Hydrogen or Oxygen
There is no such thing as organic salt…
Wouldn’t the salts derived from organic acids like citric acid technically be organic salts? Like sodium citrates for example?
Heresy!
Even the most transgenic plant, grown in the techiest greenhouse ever cared for with the nastiest fertilizers and pesticides is organic in the most widespread and commonly used meaning of the word.
The air quotes are well deserved.
Wait, what’s the most widespread and commonly used meaning of the word?
Organic is a term certified by the USDA.
To use “organic” on packaging, a product must contain at least 95% organically produced ingredients.
Love a definition that uses its own word
It is a bit annoying, though “organically produced” is defined exhaustively on the website.
We can debate what it means effectively, but the term organic in the US means something. It’s a regulated term and you can’t just slap different stickers on something and call it organic. So much just straight up misinformation in this thread from people too jaded, or too lazy, to look it up.
https://www.usda.gov/topics/organic
https://www.ams.usda.gov/rules-regulations/organic
Now I’m not saying that the regulated term “organic” doesn’t have some other weird side effects, or that people haven’t attempted to hoodwink the process, but the term itself carries the weight of regulation in the US. So it’s not some silly, “Hurrr derrr Organic means Organic” thing like people are making it out to be.
I think what we know is that it’s a scam and we don’t care.
How is it a scam? There is a whole host of rules and regulations around using the term.
Means “contains carbon” in any context other than food
When not talking about US food it just means living matter. Basically anything you eat is organic by the traditional definition. The USDA organic definition is honestly a joke though. Most pesticide other than the new age shit is made out of plant directives. Doesn’t make it safe to consume. The range of shit they can use and do, while still calling things organic is pretty laughable. You just have to avoid a few products that are widely used today. Nitrogen fertilizer and shit like roundup.
Meaning one could hypothetically spray a tomato with dioxins up to 5% of its body weight and it would still qualify as organic.
And slip some cash over to the FDA when one of their interns asks too many questions.
I mean, I wouldn’t want to eat inorganic food. What would that even be, pure salt?
Many different salts, not just NaCl. As well as many metals and some acids. But they all are micronutrients, you won’t get any calories out of them.
So it’s a diet then.
won’t get any calories out of them
Me, an intellectual: eats a chunk of uranium
I ate lead paint chips when I was a kid.
Delicious. But deadly.
McDonald’s?
Chick FIL A
I thought that was made from ground-up plundered religious artifacts or something
Spam
You can actually eat spammers, and I think doing so counts as community service
Hey now, spam is made of pork! What cuts of pork we’re talking about, well, that’s a different question.
It’s “mystery” “meat”.
Also “organic”
"organ"ic
ITT: Non-Americans and people being facetious
My definition of organic =contains carbon so = all food uless you are eating sand for some reason. Just another meaningless tag on US foods imo.
My own definition is: 30% upcharge for the same damned thing in a differently labeled package
You’re paying for the label
( looking at you too, “non-GMO” 👀 )
No, no, my food’s not genetically modified. It’s just been developed via artificial selection for thousands of years.
To be fair, genetic modification and selective breeding are not the same thing. It is funny how one is totally normal and the other is considered negative when they’re quite similar
I think some reservations can come out of the idea that the natural environment isn’t producing these genetic changes. Just to play devil’s advocate.
Edit: does nobody fucking know what devil’s advocate means? This isn’t my opinion christ. Also there’s a bit more depth to the argument though that you guys seem to be really obtuse about.
The natural world tries to kill you all the time. Why are you trusting that!?! Seriously though, both of these arguements are somewhat fallacious. Saying that GMOs are safe because, “It happens all the time in nature.” Is the same fallacy that it isn’t safe because, “It isn’t natural to accelerate the process with genetic modification.” Both are just mental shortcuts for people so they don’t have to think about the insanely complex topic of GMOs, the effects, and what the right path forward is for all of us.
I think this is somewhat strawmanning what the point of the argument in this specific case is. They’re not appealing to nature being good, that’s not the argument.
The point is that if you are genetically selecting for specific genes through modification then you are circumventing the typical process for genetic change. There are lots of unintended effects of genetic changes and there are lots of corrective mechanisms built into DNA when genetically modified through selective processes rather than direct gene splicing. Science is always slow to catch up with analysis of an entourage effect where many other small factors may influence results long term.
I’m not anti GMO and this isn’t my opinion as I think GMO products have amazing potential. I’m just sick of people on my side totally misrepresenting this argument as “hurr durr nature good.” It’s such a smooth brained take.
( looking at you too, “non-GMO” 👀 )
I’ll let someone correct me if I’m wrong but I believe carrots were never orange, as in every orange or yellow carrot you buy is GMO
Nearly every food you could theoretically consume is a GMO. The label is intentionally misleading.
Virtually everything we eat now is GMO after countless generations of selective breeding and all that. Ever read about the wild versions of common foods? Bananas, watermelons, corn, all that stuff in their completely natural wild form is unrecognizable from the monstrosities on sale in every grocery store.
Removed by mod
X USDA Organic
✓ IUPAC Organic
Do you consider a tomato a fruit as well? Organic has different meanings depending on the context, just like the culinary vs botanical version of fruits and vegetables.
deleted by creator
Source?
The source is mass (internet) hysteria from 5 or 6 years ago. The above poster’s claim is false and just silly given the slightest amount of scrutiny.
https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/taco-bell-grade-d-meat/
https://www.mashed.com/110654/truth-taco-bells-seasoned-beef/
deleted by creator
While silcon dioxide is used as a food additive, and is found naturally in a lot of food, it’s regarded as safe and even has been shown to have health benefits.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silicon_dioxide
That’s wildly different then the claim that Taco Bell was sued, and had to change formula, because they had so much “sand in their meat.”
deleted by creator
No, but saying “TB was putting sand in their meat” is wildly misleading, when talking about silica as food additive.
deleted by creator
Well it’s not made of organs…
Organish
Removed by mod
The farmer’s markets here are pretty legit, but I live in the midwest, so we have a ton of farms. I got some amazing goat cheese the other day at the farmer’s market. The problem is the prices are ridiculous so we only go once in a while.
We did discover the lady we get our dog treats from though.
Lifehacker tip: instead of buying dog treats by the ounce, just use another type of dog food as treats and buy it by the tens of pounds. If you’re excited they’re a real treat.
I do this with my cats. I get kitten kibble for them as treats. I can give them several bits cuz the kibbles are small, they love it, and even though kitten grain free food is wicked pricy, still cheaper than treats!
They normally eat wet food, but have a mix of dry stuff available at all times, so it does really work. They don’t know the difference.
Oh we’re more bougie than that. Like I said, we get dog treats from a local baker. Trust me, my dogs like them so much more than treats you could get from a store, and definitely more than a 10 pound bag of different food.
I have a local “Barkery” that makes amazing dog treats. Definitely way better than store bought, and it’s nice to support a local business. They also give my dog freebies worth more than what I’m buying most times I stop in, so I can’t complain about price too much
Yeah, I’m really happy to help this lady. She’s super nice and she just does this as a business out of her home. Every time I order, I tell her to mail it to me (and pay the extra for shipping) because I just don’t want the hassle of arranging a pickup and every time she says, “are you sure? I hate to charge you extra!” Plus, she makes dog treats that look like Indiana- where we live- which is just fun.
And then get a Mennonite to sell them. “Farm fresh mangos” in Halifax.
I for one am happy to know that the food I purchase is strictly carbon-based and doesn’t contain fillers made up from ground-up Horta carcasses or whatever.
I’m sorry to tell you this but plants contain anorganic elements. It’s less than 1% tho.
That’s unacceptable.
That’s why I avoid them
No kill I!
Some of you need to find a local farmer and it shows.
I’m in nebraska. I can find all the corn you ever could want… Not much else. Got a bitchin’ farmers market though.
I get that, I’m in WI.
More likely that everyone was ignoring him, but that don’t sound as cool on twitter
This dude - “Are these ‘organic’?”
Stall worker - “Yes. 3 dollars.”
This dude - “Really?”
Stall worker - “Sir, do you want the pears or not?”
“then all the farmers clapped and this cute farmer girl asked me to come to the next barn dance with her”
City folks just don’t get it.
I always try to avoid buying organic. I specifically will avoid purchasing something if it says organic on it
Saves you whatever they marked up the price to for adding the “organic” label.
I thought being organic meant no pesticides
It means “organic” pesticides, which are older and more dangerous to the environment.
How are older organic pesticides more dangerous to the environment??
Neem oil for example is completely safe afaik.
The newer pesticides are designed to work as effectively as possible. Due to their effectiveness, a limited amount is required to be applied to the soil. The FDA approved organic pesticides aren’t as effective. This requires additional applications and more being applied each time (vs the newer non-approved pesticides). More pesticides being applied means more runoff and possibility of contamination to streams and ground water. The soil can also be over saturated and be damaged by the increased concentration.
deleted by creator
Hey now! Don’t go rubbing organic salt in their wounds!
what kinda salt is organic ?
Yes
I guess all the annoying shit from reddit is coming over here.
